Item Details
Skip Navigation Links
   ActiveUsers:4073Hits:20936194Skip Navigation Links
Show My Basket
Contact Us
IDSA Web Site
Ask Us
Today's News
HelpExpand Help
Advanced search

In Basket
  Journal Article   Journal Article
 

ID093091
Title ProperRe-Ordering justice
Other Title InformationTowards a new methodological approach to studying transitional justice
LanguageENG
AuthorGrodsky, Brian
Publication2009.
Summary / Abstract (Note)Scholars and policymakers have turned increasing attention to questions of transitional justice, those legal responses to a former regime's repressive acts following a change in political systems. Although there is a rich, interdisciplinary literature that addresses the value of various transitional justice measures, theoretical arguments for how and under what conditions we should expect to see these measures implemented tend to gravitate to intuitively appealing relative power considerations. But attempts at parsimony have tended to leave the dependent variable either overly restrictive or poorly defined, yielding theories that are difficult to test. In this article, the author proposes a 'transitional justice spectrum' based on a hierarchical series of possible accountability mechanisms and designed to allow researchers to conduct more rigorous, cross-national tests of justice arguments. The objective here is not to posit a broad theory of transitional justice, but to open the debate into a methodological weakness in the transitional justice literature. The article includes seven accountability mechanisms: cessation and codification of human rights violations; condemnation of the old system; rehabilitation and compensation for victims; creation of a truth commission; purging human rights abusers from public function; criminal prosecution of 'executors' (those lower on the chain-of-command); criminal prosecution of commanders (those higher on the chain-of-command).
`In' analytical NoteJournal of Peace Research Vol. 46, No. 6; Nov 2009: p.819-837
Journal SourceJournal of Peace Research Vol. 46, No. 6; Nov 2009: p.819-837
Key WordsRe - Ordering Justice ;  Methodological Approach ;  Policymakers ;  Interdisciplinary Literature ;  Human Rights ;  Violations