ID | 109199 |
Title Proper | Presidency of the international tribunal for the law of the sea and the national state extension concern |
Language | ENG |
Author | Yee, Sienho |
Publication | 2011. |
Summary / Abstract (Note) | The functions of the President of the International Tribunal for the Law (ITLOS) of the Sea are three-dimensional: the President is a normal international judge, an organizational leader and a judicial leader in a particular case. The Presidency is a powerful one, perhaps more so than that in other international judicial bodies, and can be a platform for the "national State extension" vice-the President's possible partiality towards his or her national State-to take effect. Several antidotes or safeguards exist to combat this, including the relatively short term of office, the judicial solemn declaration and the efforts to equalize the parties by ensuring "national representation" on the Bench in a case, and the principle of separation of functions and the disqualification of the national President as President but not as Judge. However, uncertainties remain regarding the timing and scope of the application of the principle of separation of functions and disqualification of the national President. The context of the ITLOS Statute and Rules and the good administration of justice militate in favour of an early trigger point at the time when a particular case is first presented to the Tribunal and the widest scope possible for the application of the principle to cover a situation where the national State of the President is not a party but is in the same interest or substantially in the same interest as a party in a case, including the situation where, though not factually connected, the non-party national State of the President and a party share a legal position that is decisive in the case. Finally, the paper suggests that, as a further antidote, the possibility be considered of requiring a presidential solemn declaration (separate from and in addition to the judicial one) or revising the current judicial declaration to encompass presidential functions. |
`In' analytical Note | Chinese Journal of International Law Vol. 10, No. 4; Dec 2011: p.739-770 |
Journal Source | Chinese Journal of International Law Vol. 10, No. 4; Dec 2011: p.739-770 |
Key Words | International Tribunal ; Law of the Sea ; International Judge ; Judicial Leader ; ITLOS |