| ID | 153631 |
| Title Proper | Revisiting Hiroshima in Iran |
| Other Title Information | what Americans really think about using nuclear weapons and killing noncombatants |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Sagan, Scott D ; Valentino, Benjamin A |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | Numerous polls demonstrate that U.S. public approval of President Harry Truman's decision to drop the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki has declined significantly since 1945. Many scholars and political figures argue that this decline constitutes compelling evidence of the emergence of a “nuclear taboo” or that the principle of noncombatant immunity has become a deeply held norm. An original survey experiment, recreating the situation that the United States faced in 1945 using a hypothetical U.S. war with Iran today, provides little support for the nuclear taboo thesis. In addition, it suggests that the U.S. public's support for the principle of noncombatant immunity is shallow and easily overcome by the pressures of war. When considering the use of nuclear weapons, the majority of Americans prioritize protecting U.S. troops and achieving American war aims, even when doing so would result in the deliberate killing of millions of foreign noncombatants. A number of individual-level traits—Republican Party identification, older age, and approval of the death penalty for convicted murderers—significantly increase support for using nuclear weapons against Iran. Women are no less willing (and, in some scenarios, more willing) than men to support nuclear weapons use. These findings highlight the limited extent to which the U.S. public has accepted the principles of just war doctrine and suggest that public opinion is unlikely to be a serious constraint on any president contemplating the use of nuclear weapons in the crucible of war. |
| `In' analytical Note | International Security Vol. 42, No.1; Summer 2017: p.41-79 |
| Journal Source | International Security Vol: 42 No 1 |
| Key Words | Nuclear Weapons ; Iran ; United States ; Hiroshima ; Nuclear Taboo ; Pressures of War |