| Summary/Abstract |
The impact of finding life beyond Earth, whether microbial, complex, or intelligent, is an important and timely problem given recent discoveries in the field of astrobiology. Analogy is one of the tools that may be used cautiously to explore potential impacts of discovering extraterrestrial life under different scenarios. After a brief examination of the problems and promise of analogy, this article suggests four analogs useful for providing guidelines in the event of such a discovery: the microbe analogy, the culture contact analogy, the transmission/translation analogy, and the worldview analogy. We offer what we term the “Goldilocks Principle of Analogy”: analogy must not be so general as to be meaningless, nor so specific as to be misleading. As in other fields, the middle “Goldilocks” ground is where analogies may serve as useful guideposts for astrobiology and its impact. And although the discovery of life beyond Earth will be a unique event, these guidelines may be useful for policy decisions both before and after the discovery of life.
|