ID | 082035 |
Title Proper | Culture as an activity and human right |
Other Title Information | an important advance for indigenous peoples and international law |
Language | ENG |
Author | Holder, Cindy |
Publication | 2008. |
Summary / Abstract (Note) | Historically, culture has been treated as an object in international documents. One consequence of this is that cultural rights in international law have been understood as rights of access and consumption. Recently, an alternative conception of culture, and of what cultural rights protect, has emerged from international documents treating indigenous peoples. Within these documents culture is treated as an activity rather than a good. This activity is ascribed to peoples as well as persons, and protecting the capacity of both peoples and persons to engage in culture is taken to be as basic a component of human dignity as are freedom of movement, freedom of speech, and freedom from torture. It is not an accident that this treatment of culture has emerged from international documents treating indigenous peoples, for indigenous peoples' cultural rights can be fully understood only against the background of their basic rights to self-determination. However, the value of this treatment of culture extends beyond the human rights of indigenous peoples. Treating culture as an activity establishes an understanding of what cultural rights protect that clarifies the relationship between cultural rights and other mechanisms for protecting minorities and frames the role of cultural communities in the realization of human dignity as an important physical and political issue, not just a psychological one. This article offers an account of what is wrong with violating cultural rights that clearly and straightforwardly links violations of a group's cultural rights to violations of its rights to persist and to flourish. For these reasons, the norms regarding cultural rights that are emerging from international documents treating indigenous peoples are a much-needed step forward for peoples' rights more generally |
`In' analytical Note | Alternatives Vol. 33, No.1; Jan-Mar 2008: p7-28 |
Journal Source | Alternatives Vol. 33, No.1; Jan-Mar 2008: p7-28 |
Key Words | Sovereignty ; Indigenous Cultural ; Rights ; International Politics ; Human Rights |