| ID | 095067 |
| Title Proper | Defence dilemma in Britain |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Edmunds, Timothy |
| Publication | 2010. |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | The UK faces a pressing defence dilemma. The declaratory goals of defence policy are struggling to match the demands made by operational commitments and the financial and organizational capacities. The article examines how and why this situation has come about. While recognizing that existing calls for higher defence spending, reform of the Ministry of Defence, efficiency gains or a renewal of the so-called military covenant between the military and society may address discrete elements of the defence dilemma in Britain, it argues that current problems derive from a series of deeper tensions in the nexus of British defence more widely defined. These include a transnationalization of strategic practice, in ways that both shape and constrain the national defence policy process; the institutional politics of defence itself, which encourage different interpretations of interest and priority in the wider strategic context; and finally the changing status of defence in the wider polity, which introduces powerful veto points into the defence policy process itself. It argues that while a series of shocks may have destabilized existing policy, prompted ad hoc organizational adaptation in the armed forces and led to incremental cost saving measures from the government, a 'dominant crisis narrative'-in the form of a distinctive and generally agreed programme of change-has yet to emerge. The article concludes by looking forward to a future strategic defence review, highlighting the critical path dependencies and veto points which must be addressed if transformative change in British defence is to take place. |
| `In' analytical Note | International Affairs Vol. 86, No. 2; Mar 2010: p.377-394 |
| Journal Source | International Affairs Vol. 86, No. 2; Mar 2010: p.377-394 |
| Key Words | Defence Dilemma ; Britain ; Defence Policy ; United Kingdom |