| ID | 109978 |
| Title Proper | But where are "the people"? unfinished agendas in the people of Puerto Rico |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Giusti-Cordero, Juan A |
| Publication | 2011. |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | The People of Puerto Rico is a comprehensive ethnography of major types of rural communities in pre-1950 Puerto Rico but was less successful in reconnecting those localities in a coherent portrayal of the island's social formation. A reexamination of this work's best-known subcultures, Santa Isabel (Sidney Mintz' "Cañamelar") and Ciales (Eric Wolf's "San José"), offers entry points to these communities, as well as to the key concepts that Mintz and Wolf constructed reciprocally through their research: rural proletarian and peasant, plantation and hacienda. Also present are the too-implicit spatial referents of these concepts-lowland and highland, foreland and hinterland-and their associated crop types, sugar and coffee. In this article, the historical space of Santa Isabel and Ciales will be reconsidered, in part with reference to often-overlooked nuances and caveats in Mintz' and Wolf's chapters. Foregrounding the spatial/ecological referent in "Cañamelar" and "San José" opens our sights to counterpoints between sugar and livestock, and to patterns of highland-lowland migration, kin networks, and social interaction. Familiar concepts take on new meanings as we discern supra-municipal, sub-insular, and intermediate island regions and move closer to specifying historical situations (Mintz) while renewing our theorization (Wolf). |
| `In' analytical Note | Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power Vol. 18, No.1-3; May-Jun 2011: p.203-217 |
| Journal Source | Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power Vol. 18, No.1-3; May-Jun 2011: p.203-217 |
| Key Words | Puerto Rico ; Mintz Wolf ; Highlands ; Lowlands ; Peasants ; Plantations ; Rural Proletarians ; Space ; Ecology |