| ID | 139411 |
| Title Proper | Saved and the drowned |
| Other Title Information | governing indifference in the name of security |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Basaran, Tugba |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | The duty to render assistance at sea appears to be a well-established humanitarian norm; nonetheless, in 2011 alone more than 1500 people drowned in the Mediterranean. Witnesses recount that many could have been rescued if fellow seafarers had not ignored their pleas for help. Struggling to understand failures to rescue, many seek to portray indifference as individual failure from the norm. In contrast hereto, this article provides an insight into the governing of indifference in contemporary liberal societies - that is, how people are guided towards becoming indifferent to the lives and sufferings of particular populations. Thus, my focus will be on the workings of law and its potential to produce collective indifference. The drowned, I argue, are not casualties of individual immoral behaviour; through a system of sanctions, fellow human beings are encouraged to look away and even to let people die at borders in the name of security. This not only dilutes the legal duty to rescue but has also had a detrimental impact upon the normative landscape, leading to a distinction between worthy lives that fall within the duty to rescue and charitable lives becoming a question of benevolence. |
| `In' analytical Note | Security Dialogue Vol. 46, No.3; Jun 2015: p.205-220 |
| Journal Source | Security Dialogue Vol: 46 No 3 |
| Key Words | Security ; Borders ; Law ; Migrants ; Rescue ; Indifference |