| ID | 143288 |
| Title Proper | Concordance theory in Pakistan |
| Other Title Information | response to Zulfiqar Ali |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Schiff, Rebecca L |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | In Zulfiqar Ali’s article regarding concordance theory in Pakistan, Dr. Ali asserts that concordance theory does not explain domestic military intervention in Pakistan. He also suggests that concordance theory superimposes a Western theoretical model on Pakistan, like Huntington’s theory of objective civilian control. In response to Dr. Ali’s claims, this article reiterates how concordance theory can in fact explain why Pakistan has suffered from domestic military intervention—the alienation of the Bengali community and subsequent lack of agreement among the three concordance partners being one significant factor. Additionally, Huntington’s theory focuses on institutional and dichotomous civil–military relations, grounded in the post–World War II US case study. By contrast, concordance theory views the relationship between military and society from both cultural and institutional perspectives and embraces those indigenous qualities that may encourage or discourage domestic military intervention. |
| `In' analytical Note | Armed Forces and Society Vol. 42, No.1; Jan 2016: p.226-234 |
| Journal Source | Armed Forces and Society Vol: 42 No 1 |
| Key Words | Pakistan ; Military Coups ; Concordance Theory |