| ID | 155674 |
| Title Proper | Missing girls, indirect measures and critical assumptions |
| Other Title Information | a response to Yong Cai's comments |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Shi, Yaojiang ; Kennedy, John James |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | We thank Yong Cai for his comments and insights regarding our piece on the “missing girls.” We also recognize and appreciate his expertise in the field of population studies. In short, we agree that we have overestimated the number of nominally missing girls and that the number of hidden or recovered girls may be closer to 10 million or half of the truly missing girls rather than 15 million. Of course, the number of truly missing girls is inconclusive due to the lack of direct measures and the reliance on proxy measures such as previous census data, surveys and state education data. Given the absence of direct measures for the truly missing, scholars also rely on assumptions of villager behaviour and local policy implementation, such as the continued prevalence of son preference as well as the implementation of birth control measures across rural China. Our aim for the “missing girls” article is not to solely challenge the numbers (because we realize the margin of error is in the millions), but we want to challenge the social and political assumptions behind the truly missing. Therefore, we believe the debate over the general estimates of the truly missing is real and should continue. |
| `In' analytical Note | China Quarterly vol. ,No.231; Sep 2017: p.804-810 |
| Journal Source | China Quarterly No 231 |
| Key Words | China ; Missing Girls ; Indirect Measures ; Critical Assumptions |