| ID | 175125 |
| Title Proper | Jew and the tank |
| Other Title Information | Habit and habitus towards a theodicy of war |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Monk, Daniel Bertrand |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | Histories of the Arab–Israeli War of 1967 have advanced a curious commonplace. As they have sought to account for the decisive factors in what they treat as a decisive war, soldiers and interpreters of their arguments have tacitly resorted to what Adolf Loos once referred to as a ‘principle of cladding’, or bekleidungsprinzip, in order to explain the successes of Israel’s armored corps. The bekleidungsprinzip is not a military principle but a dictum of fashion, according to which the renunciation of individual affect in dress is presumed to coincide with the emergence of the qualitative advantages of the modern. With little or no explanation to substantiate the relation between dress and success in armored warfare, histories of this war have instead explained that the causes of a decisive victory may have to be found in the relation between uniforms and technical uniformity. This presupposition possesses an intellectual history, in the course of which war intellectuals repeatedly sought to reconcile what they themselves posed as a contradiction between agency and structure by identifying a proper relation between habit and habitus. Elaborated in a series of doctrinal debates concerning the proper relation of the Jew to the tank in the Israel Defense Forces – and in subsequent interpretations of those disputes – the bekleidung argument is more than a mere curiosity of military history. It points, instead, to a theodicy of conflict according to which a reification of this history’s false premises presents itself to view in repeated images of their transcendence. |
| `In' analytical Note | Security Dialogue Vol. 51, No.2-3; Apr-Jun 2020: p.248-267 |
| Journal Source | Security Dialogue Vol 51 No 2-3 |
| Key Words | Critical Theory ; Adorno ; Israel Defense Forces ; Armored Warfare ; Bourdieu ; Arab–Israeli War 1967 |