| ID | 187536 |
| Title Proper | Role and relation in Confucian IR |
| Other Title Information | Relating to strangers in the states of nature |
| Language | ENG |
| Author | Chih-Yu Shih ; Shih, Chih-Yu |
| Summary / Abstract (Note) | The literature on International Relations theory has yet to align relational theory with role theory, despite the fact that these two theories share so much epistemological common ground. This article uses role theory to bridge the gap between the Confucian and Western conceptions of relationality, whose practitioners regard each other as strangers. With the support of role theory, the comparative analysis of relationality in this article has mainly focused on two different types of relations: prior rule-based relations and improvised relations. The differences in the cultural preparation for these two relations partially explain the plurality of the relational universe and the perception of stranger. Role theory is one way to reconnect the seemingly irreconcilable relational universes. To illustrate the value of a composite agenda of relational theory and role theory, the article will use Kim Jong-un of North Korea as its case. Confucian relations propose that, for all nations, the necessity of having a certain role relation is a more important agenda than insisting on exactly what role to take. |
| `In' analytical Note | Review of International Studies Vol. 48, No.5; Dec 2022: p.910 - 929 |
| Journal Source | Review of International Studies Vol: 48 No 5 |
| Key Words | Confucianism ; State of Nature ; Relational Theory ; Role Theory ; Stranger ; Tianxia ; Gift Giving |