Search Result

Srl

Item

ID: 078495

Causation, Counterfactuals, and Critical Reading in the Active / Ripley, Brian

Ripley, Brian	Journal Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Publication

2007.

Key Words

Social Science ; Pedagogy ; Causal Reasoning ; Reading Assignments ; Counterfactuals

In Basket

Export

ID: 141968

Counterfactuals and security studies / Lebow, Richard Ned

Lebow, Richard Ned	Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

Cause is a cognitive shorthand, not a feature of the world. Context is almost invariably critical in shaping outcomes. For both these reasons, correlations in international relations are weak and all but useless for purposes of explanation and prediction. I develop “inefficient causation” as an alternative approach to explanation and forecasting. It divides the causal problem into two components: reasons actors have for behaving as they do, and the aggregation of the behavior of multiple actors. Both make use of comparative and counterfactual analysis.

Key Words

Security Studies ; Counterfactuals ; International Relations ; Correlations

Links

'Full Text'

In Basket

Export

ID: 141967

Counterfactuals, causal inference, and historical analysis / Levy, Jack S

Levy, Jack S	Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

I focus primarily on the utility of counterfactual analysis for helping to validate causal inferences in historical analysis. How can we use what did not happen but which easily could have happened to understand what did happen? With an infinite number of things that might have happened, and with temptations to construct “counterfactuals of convenience” to bolster one's preferred historical interpretations or political preferences, we need a set of rules or best practices for evaluating the scientific legitimacy of counterfactuals. Building on earlier work in several disciplines, I develop a set of criteria for the conduct of counterfactual analysis in historical case studies. The best counterfactuals begin with clearly specified plausible worlds involving small and easily imaginable changes from the real world. They make relatively short-term predictions based on empirically validated theoretical generalizations and on secondary counterfactuals that are mutually consistent. These counterfactuals are also sensitive to strategic behavior that might return history to its original course, and they are explicitly tested against competing counterfactuals.

Key Words

Counterfactuals ; Historical Analysis ; Causal Inference

Links

'Full Text'

In Basket

Export