Search Result

Srl

Item

ID: 138280

Coalition and the politics of the English question / Hayton, Richard

Hayton, Richard	Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

For much of the 2010–15 Parliament the English Question was not a conspicuous feature of political debate in the UK. However, the issue of English votes for English laws (EvfEl) was thrust to centre stage by Prime Minister David Cameron in the aftermath of the Scottish independence referendum, when he announced that fulfilment of the promise of further devolution to Scotland must be accompanied by an answer to the West Lothian Question at Westminster. This article analyses these events and explores their possible consequences. It argues that a reform of parliamentary procedures along the lines outlined in the report of the McKay Commission looks increasingly likely, but that this will not mark a resolution of the broader English Question, and the future of the Union remains in doubt.

Key Words

West Lothian Question ; English Votes for English Laws ; EvfEl ; Scottish Independence Referendum ; English Question ; McKay Commission ;
Devo Max

In Basket

Export

ID: 084897

Devolution, equity and the English question / Bryant, Christopher G A

Bryant, Christopher G A	Journal Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Publication

2008.

Summary/Abstract

Following devolution to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, does England need a stronger political voice and/or constitutional changes to safeguard its identity and interests? (the 'English question'). Polling and other evidence suggests that it does, albeit more to redress inequities associated with voting in parliament (the 'West Lothian question') and the distribution of public spending (the 'Barnett formula') than to safeguard its identity. Although campaigners for English devolution have had little impact, and alternative institutional responses to the English question are all problematic, it would be imprudent of the major parties to do nothing. The least difficult course would be adoption of English votes on English matters and reform or replacement of the Barnett formula.

Key Words

Devolution - England ; Barnett Formula -English Question ; West Lothian Question

In Basket

Export