Search Result

Srl

Item

ID: 087854

Capitalism, uneven and combined development and the transhistor / Ashman, Sam

Ashman, Sam	Journal Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Publication

2009.

Summary/Abstract

What is the status of Trotsky's notion of uneven and combined development within Marxist theory and how might it be fruitfully employed by Marxists in international relations? Is uneven and combined development a transhistoric general abstraction or does it need rooting in the relations, processes, tendencies and counter-tendencies of a particular mode of production? This article rejects Justin Rosenberg's recently drawn conclusion that uneven and combined development is usefully understood as a transhistoric general abstraction that potentially offers the basis of a transhistoric theory of the international. Instead it questions the value of transhistoric categories for Marxist theory and pursues the argument that uneven and combined development is best understood within the relations, processes and tendencies of the capitalist mode of production, arguing that capitalist social relations and political forms are historically unique in their capacity to generate both combination and unevenness.

Key Words

Capitalism ; Uneven ; Combined Development ; Transhistoric

Links

'Full Text'

In Basket

Export

ID: 186290

Uneven and combined development: a defense of the general abstraction / Rosenberg, Justin

Rosenberg, Justin	Journal Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

This article responds to criticisms of the current revival of Uneven and Combined Development (UCD), particularly those aimed at the idea of a ‘general abstraction’ of UCD. Three main charges have been pressed: that UCD is not a real theory; that its transhistorical extension has reduced it to an unhistorical reification; and that its language of ‘advanced’ and ‘backward’ betrays its enduring Eurocentric foundations. The article argues not only that UCD can be defended, but also that it is the general abstraction which enables UCD to make its strongest contributions to solving problems of theoretical insufficiency, ahistoricism and Eurocentrism in social thought more generally. Finally the article ends by speculating on the reason why the much-maligned general abstraction of UCD should turn out to be of such significance.

Key Words

Uneven ; Combined Development ; UCD

Links

'Full Text'

In Basket

Export