Search Result

Srl

Item

ID: 142021

China's rise and the ‘Chinese dream’ in international relations theory / Do, Thuy T

Do, Thuy T	Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

The rise of China/East Asia and the perceived decline of the US/West pose an emerging question about how international relations (IR) theory should respond to this change. Increasingly, there have been heated discussions among Chinese IR academics over a desirable Chinese contribution to IR theory (IRT), particularly the possibility of building a distinctive Chinese IRT. Inevitably, this drive towards theorizing from a Chinese perspective also creates a backlash among not only Western but also other Chinese scholars as they question the ‘nationalistic’ if not ‘hegemonic’ discourse of the scholarship. Drawing on the sociology of scientific knowledge framework, this article examines the linkages between the vibrant dynamics of the Chinese theoretical debates and the actual practices of Chinese scholars in realizing their claims. It suggests that this investigation can serve as a springboard into a better appreciation of the theory–practice and power–knowledge relationships in the context of Chinese IR.

Key Words

Sociology of knowledge ; Chinese School ; Tsinghua Approach ; Tianxia ; East Asian IR ; Non-Western IR Theory

Links

'Full Text'

In Basket

Export

ID: 163107

East Asia international relations and international relations theory: where does a poor fit exist, and what to do about it / Kim, Min-hyung

Kim, Min-hyung	Journal Article
	0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)

Summary/Abstract

This article seeks to critically assess the relevance of International Relations Theory (IRT) for East Asia International Relations (IR). After identifying the shortcomings of IRT in explaining East Asia IR, the article provides several ways to modify it with a goal to make it more suitable for East Asia IR. Its central claim is that the IRT’s bias toward European experiences and great power politics generates unsatisfactory accounts for and inaccurate predictions about East Asia IR. This does not mean, however, that we should treat IRT as completely irrelevant and develop an indigenous theory of East Asia IR. Given that no single theory is complete and perfectly relevant across time and space and that many core concepts and key variables of IRT are also pertinent for East Asia IR, our efforts should instead be made to refine the existing IRT and make it more suitable for East Asia IR by problematising its major assumptions and central claims on the basis of East Asian experiences. This will save IRT from being a region-specific and a country-specific theory of IR.

Key Words

International Relations Theory ; East Asian IR ; East Asian State Behavior ; East Asian Experiences ; East Asian Institutions

In Basket

Export