Query Result Set
Skip Navigation Links
   ActiveUsers:4671Hits:25707670Skip Navigation Links
Show My Basket
Contact Us
IDSA Web Site
Ask Us
Today's News
HelpExpand Help
Advanced search

  Hide Options
Sort Order Items / Page
SIDA LIU, CHING-FANG HSU AND TERENCE C. HALLIDAY (1) answer(s).
 
SrlItem
1
ID:   166099


Law as a Sword, Law as a Shield : Politically Liberal Lawyers and the Rule of Law in China / Liu, Sida ; Halliday, Terence C. ; Hsu, Ching-Fang   Journal Article
Sida Liu, Ching-Fang Hsu and Terence C. Halliday Journal Article
0 Rating(s) & 0 Review(s)
Summary/Abstract What does the rule of law mean in the Chinese context? Based on empirical research in Beijing and Hong Kong, this article examines the various ways politically liberal lawyers in China make sense of the rule of law in their discourses and collective action. Although the rule of law is frequently invoked by lawyers as a legitimating discourse against the authoritarian state, its use in practice is primarily for instrumental purposes, as both a sword and a shield. For activist lawyers in Beijing, the pursuit of judicial independence is nothing but a distant dream involving a restructuring of the state, and they therefore focus their mobilisation for rule of law around basic legal freedoms and the growth of civil society. By contrast, Hong Kong lawyers hold the autonomy of their judiciary as a paramount value mainly because it is a powerful defensive weapon against Beijing’s political influence. The rule of law as a shield is only effective where its institutional and normative foundations are solid (as in Hong Kong), and it becomes little more than a blunt sword for lawyers where such foundations are weak or missing (as in mainland China).
Key Words Authoritarianism  China  Hong Kong  Rule of Law  Political liberalism  Lawyer 
        Export Export